| Windfall (2022)As Nobody | (Not seen) |
| Our Friend (2019)As Dane Faucheux | (Not seen) |
| Come Sunday (2018)As Henry | (Not seen) |
| The Discovery (2017)As Will Harbor | (Not seen) |
| The End of the Tour (2015)As David Foster Wallace | (Not seen) |
| Sex Tape (2014)As Jay | (Not seen) |
| This Is the End (2013)As Himself (uncredited) | (Not seen) |
| This Is 40 (2012)As Jason | (Not seen) |
| The Five-Year Engagement (2012)As Tom Solomon | (Not seen) |
| Jeff, Who Lives at Home (2011)As Jeff | (Not seen) |
| Bad Teacher (2011)As Russell Gettis | (Not seen) |
| The Muppets (2011)As Gary | (Not seen) |
| Friends with Benefits (2011) (AKA "Stay Friends")As Brice (uncredited) | (Not seen) |
| Gulliver's Travels (2010)As Horatio | (Not seen) |
| Despicable Me (2010)As Vector (voice) | (Not seen) |
| I Love You, Man (2009) (AKA "Let's Make Friends")As Sydney Fife | (Not seen) |
| Forgetting Sarah Marshall (2008)As Peter Bretter | (Not seen) |
| Knocked Up (2007)As Jason | (Not seen) |
| 11:14 (2003)As Leon | (Not seen) |
| Slackers (2002) (AKA "Hooking Up Ethan")As Sam Schechter | (Not seen) |
| SLC Punk! (1998) (AKA "SLC Punk")As Mike | (Not seen) |
| Dead Man on Campus (1998)As Kyle | (Not seen) |
| Can't Hardly Wait (1998)As Matt | (Not seen) |