| Trolls Band Together (2023) As King Gristle (voice) | (Not seen) |
| Honor Society (2022) As Mr. Calvin | (Not seen) |
| Promising Young Woman (2020) As Neil | (Not seen) |
| The Disaster Artist (2017) As Sid (uncredited) | (Not seen) |
| Trolls (2016) As Prince Gristle (voice) | (Not seen) |
| Neighbors 2: Sorority Rising (2016) (AKA "Bad Neighbours 2") As Scoonie Schofield | (Not seen) |
| Neighbors (2014) (AKA "Bad Neighbours") As Scoonie Schofield | (Not seen) |
| How to Train Your Dragon 2 (2014) As Fishlegs (voice) | (Not seen) |
| Movie 43 (2013) As Mikey (segment "Middleschool Date") | (Not seen) |
| The To Do List (2013) As Duffy | (Not seen) |
| This Is the End (2013) As Himself | (Not seen) |
| Kick-Ass 2 (2013) As Chris D'Amico / The Motherfucker | (Not seen) |
| ParaNorman (2012) As Alvin (voice) | (Not seen) |
| Pitch Perfect (2012) As Tommy | (Not seen) |
| Dragons: Gift of the Night Fury (2011) As Fishlegs (voice) | (Not seen) |
| Fright Night (2011) As Ed Thompson | (Not seen) |
| Marmaduke (2010) As Giuseppe (voice) | (Not seen) |
| How to Train Your Dragon (2010) (AKA "Dragons") As Fishlegs Ingerman (voice) | (Not seen) |
| Kick-Ass (2010) As Chris D'Amico / Red Mist | (Not seen) |
| Year One (2009) (AKA "The Year One") As Isaac | (Not seen) |
| Role Models (2008) (AKA "Big Brothers") As Augie Farks | (Not seen) |
| Superbad (2007) (AKA "Separation Anxiety") As Fogell | (Not seen) |